Are GDs just dual layer CDs?

General Dreamcast discussion applies here. Before posting here please check the other forums in the Dreamcast section to see if your topic would fit better in those categories.
Forum rules
Please check the other forums in the Dreamcast section before posting here to see if your topic would fit better in those categories. Example: A new game/homebrew release would go in the New Releases/Homebrew/Emulation section: http://dreamcast-talk.com/forum/viewforum.php?f=5 or if you're having an issue with getting your Dreamcast to work or a game to boot it would go in the Support section: http://dreamcast-talk.com/forum/viewforum.php?f=42
Savlon
shadow
Posts: 12
Dreamcast Games you play Online: None as of now

Re: Are GDs just dual layer CDs?

Post by Savlon »

Ian Micheal wrote:people would be still using a gdemu and we can have now 2gb images on gdemu so job done
Yes?

User avatar
Ian Micheal
Developer
Posts: 6285
Location: USA
Contact:

Re: Are GDs just dual layer CDs?

Post by Ian Micheal »

Savlon wrote:
Ian Micheal wrote:people would be still using a gdemu and we can have now 2gb images on gdemu so job done
Yes?
Yes easy to make up to 2gb image and run it on gdemu could remake retail games or have homebrew with up to 2gb of space corse you cant burn it ..

but real disks are going the way of the DoDO

Savlon
shadow
Posts: 12
Dreamcast Games you play Online: None as of now

Re: Are GDs just dual layer CDs?

Post by Savlon »

Ian Micheal wrote:
Savlon wrote:
Ian Micheal wrote:people would be still using a gdemu and we can have now 2gb images on gdemu so job done
Yes?
Yes easy to make up to 2gb image and run it on gdemu could remake retail games or have homebrew with up to 2gb of space corse you cant burn it ..

but real disks are going the way of the DoDO
I don't see how this is relevant or what it was a response to but OK, thank you for the info. I didn't know that you could use 2gb images with GDemu.

User avatar
Ian Micheal
Developer
Posts: 6285
Location: USA
Contact:

Re: Are GDs just dual layer CDs?

Post by Ian Micheal »

Savlon wrote:
Ian Micheal wrote:
Savlon wrote:
Yes?
Yes easy to make up to 2gb image and run it on gdemu could remake retail games or have homebrew with up to 2gb of space corse you cant burn it ..

but real disks are going the way of the DoDO
I don't see how this is relevant or what it was a response to but OK, thank you for the info. I didn't know that you could use 2gb images with GDemu.
Your ? Are GDs just dual layer CDs?

No there not but there was 99min cdrs which was almost the same 870mb normal cdr that the dreamcast can read and or a normal cd drive
with some work pretty much all gdroms can be made to fit with out any loss of detail
The GD-ROM in the Dreamcast works in constant angular velocity (CAV) mode, like the majority of modern optical drives. Very old CD-ROM drives read with a constant linear velocity (CLV) design, however (usually 12× or slower). Sega achieved the higher density by decreasing the speed of the disc to half and by letting the standard CD-ROM components read at the normal rate thus nearly doubling the disc's data density. This method allowed Sega to use cheaper off-the-shelf components when building the Dreamcast.

User avatar
WedgeStratos
blackout!
Posts: 135
Dreamcast Games you play Online: From AFO to WebTV
Contact:

Re: Are GDs just dual layer CDs?

Post by WedgeStratos »

Savlon wrote:Yes I've seen the wikipedia page but thanks for quoting it for anyone else that reads. I wonder if anyone who has contributed to it is on this forum? Also i don't really understand why it was used for TriForce and Chihiro. They wouldn't exactly be thinking about that level of cost cutting in an arcade machine. Am I wrong?
The Naomi had the GD-ROM unit available but that system actually preloads assets into a cache on the GD-ROM unit to act as substitute ROM since the Naomi's design was still around a sort of cartridge. Given Yamaha and Sega's collaboration, they did what made sense to them, and so, GD-ROM is what Sega stuck with for those 4 arcade systems. It did also provide a decent baseline for the same security that exists on the Dreamcast, sans MIL-CD. No other systems are built with the MIL-CD spec, so it's nearly impossible to rip and bootleg those GD-ROM games without having a firmware-hacked CD drive. Combined with how arcade hardware isn't usually available to consumers, this was an effective protection.

At least it's not the CPS boards with the suicide battery (where a decryption key is stored in memory, and that memory is volatile. Battery dies, game key dies, your arcade PCB becomes a paperweight).

Savlon
shadow
Posts: 12
Dreamcast Games you play Online: None as of now

Re: Are GDs just dual layer CDs?

Post by Savlon »

Ian Micheal wrote:
Savlon wrote:
Ian Micheal wrote: Yes easy to make up to 2gb image and run it on gdemu could remake retail games or have homebrew with up to 2gb of space corse you cant burn it ..

but real disks are going the way of the DoDO
I don't see how this is relevant or what it was a response to but OK, thank you for the info. I didn't know that you could use 2gb images with GDemu.
Your ? Are GDs just dual layer CDs?

No there not but there was 99min cdrs which was almost the same 870mb normal cdr that the dreamcast can read and or a normal cd drive
with some work pretty much all gdroms can be made to fit with out any loss of detail
The GD-ROM in the Dreamcast works in constant angular velocity (CAV) mode, like the majority of modern optical drives. Very old CD-ROM drives read with a constant linear velocity (CLV) design, however (usually 12× or slower). Sega achieved the higher density by decreasing the speed of the disc to half and by letting the standard CD-ROM components read at the normal rate thus nearly doubling the disc's data density. This method allowed Sega to use cheaper off-the-shelf components when building the Dreamcast.
Ah, alright. Just thought it would be nice for clarification since all sources seemed to quote the same thing. What wikipedia says must be literally true then. Thanks. I like the glow thing too.

Savlon
shadow
Posts: 12
Dreamcast Games you play Online: None as of now

Re: Are GDs just dual layer CDs?

Post by Savlon »

WedgeStratos wrote:
Savlon wrote:Yes I've seen the wikipedia page but thanks for quoting it for anyone else that reads. I wonder if anyone who has contributed to it is on this forum? Also i don't really understand why it was used for TriForce and Chihiro. They wouldn't exactly be thinking about that level of cost cutting in an arcade machine. Am I wrong?
The Naomi had the GD-ROM unit available but that system actually preloads assets into a cache on the GD-ROM unit to act as substitute ROM since the Naomi's design was still around a sort of cartridge. Given Yamaha and Sega's collaboration, they did what made sense to them, and so, GD-ROM is what Sega stuck with for those 4 arcade systems. It did also provide a decent baseline for the same security that exists on the Dreamcast, sans MIL-CD. No other systems are built with the MIL-CD spec, so it's nearly impossible to rip and bootleg those GD-ROM games without having a firmware-hacked CD drive. Combined with how arcade hardware isn't usually available to consumers, this was an effective protection.

At least it's not the CPS boards with the suicide battery (where a decryption key is stored in memory, and that memory is volatile. Battery dies, game key dies, your arcade PCB becomes a paperweight).
Ah, OK. They were just sticking with the technology they invested in then? Getting their money's worth. And the copy protection thing as well.

User avatar
Vgesoterica
Gold Lion
Posts: 1600
Dreamcast Games you play Online: Phantasy Star / Bomberman

Re: Are GDs just dual layer CDs?

Post by Vgesoterica »

yesterday I was capturing some Dreamcast footage and my wife walked in and heard the GD-Rom drive and said "is your thing breaking"....

no...it just sounds like its dying by nature lol

User avatar
Ian Micheal
Developer
Posts: 6285
Location: USA
Contact:

Re: Are GDs just dual layer CDs?

Post by Ian Micheal »

Vgesoterica wrote:yesterday I was capturing some Dreamcast footage and my wife walked in and heard the GD-Rom drive and said "is your thing breaking"....

no...it just sounds like its dying by nature lol
I have always loved the chainsaw sound .. lets you know it means it.. Gdemu needs this effect to be a real dreamcast

User avatar
la-li-lu-le-lo
undertow
Posts: 26

Re: Are GDs just dual layer CDs?

Post by la-li-lu-le-lo »

Vgesoterica wrote:yesterday I was capturing some Dreamcast footage and my wife walked in and heard the GD-Rom drive and said "is your thing breaking"....

no...it just sounds like its dying by nature lol
At least it's not as bad as the original Xbox 360's drive. That thing sounds like a jet engine.
Ian Micheal wrote:I have always loved the chainsaw sound .. lets you know it means it.. Gdemu needs this effect to be a real dreamcast
It is weird to play games on the DC without the sound of the GD-ROM drive. Feels almost like another system.

  • Similar Topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post
  • Pseudo dual analog pinout
    by rudiment » » in Lounge
    5 Replies
    5607 Views
    Last post by rudiment
  • Possible Ideas for Dual Analog input for Indie Game
    by mrneo240 » » in Lounge
    26 Replies
    20618 Views
    Last post by Ian Micheal
  • Dual Analog -sega Dreamcast (real mod) 2020
    by MashDC43 » » in New Games
    19 Replies
    24130 Views
    Last post by MashDC43